My twin sister Lora and I dressed up as patty and Selma from the Simpsons. We had never seen patty and Selma costumes before, so we thought we would try it. We bought the wigs, but cut and painted them ourselves. The dresses we made by a neighbor and the accessories were bought and painted by us.
The bodysuits were bought from Welovecolors.com and were exactly what we were looking for, and the body paint was from a local costume shop. We were told not to use spray paint on a synthetic wig, but we did and it turn out very well, so give it a try next time (we were warned that the wig would melt).
The eyes were the hardest part to do, we used sunglasses with the lenses popped out and pushed in a lightweight baseball that had been cut in half and used paper mache to fill in the extra space on the sides.
…and because we always get asked, Patty is in the pink dress, Selma is in the blue.
Related costumes:
Coolest Doug, Patty, and Skeeter Group Costume 
Coolest Homemade Patty and Selma Twins Costumes 
Creative Tim Burton’s 9 the Movie Costume 
65+ Coolest Homemade SpongeBob Costume Ideas 
Awesome Family Guy Group Costume 
Affordable DIY Quail Man and Patty Mayonnaise Couple Halloween Costume 
65+ Coolest Homemade Thomas the Train Halloween Costume Ideas 
One of a Kind Homemade Groot Costume
Dear God this is amazing